A low appraisal does not automatically cancel your New Braunfels home sale or require you to reduce the price. Start with the buyer’s financing, the signed contract and its deadlines. Then compare a supported valuation review, a price change and buyer cash. Your best next step depends on which solution can actually close and what you would net.

Separate the appraisal shortfall from the buyer’s cash problem

The contract price is the amount you agreed to accept. The lender’s appraisal is a valuation used in the financing process. A difference between them raises a new question: can this buyer still complete this purchase under the agreed terms?

Fannie Mae’s purchase-loan LTV guidance, checked November 17, 2026, generally uses the lower of the sale price or current appraised value. The borrower’s loan program and lender determine the actual financing available. Avoid treating the appraisal as the exact amount the bank will lend.

Hypothetical example, not a New Braunfels price estimate: a $400,000 contract appraises at $380,000. Assume the lender permits an 80% loan-to-value ratio and approves that structure. The $20,000 value difference would reduce the modeled loan from $320,000 to $304,000. Keeping the $400,000 price would require $96,000 toward the price instead of $80,000: $16,000 more, before closing costs and other adjustments.

Possible agreementIllustrative loan at 80% LTVBuyer funds toward price
Keep $400,000 price$304,000$96,000
Reduce price to $390,000$304,000$86,000
Reduce price to $380,000$304,000$76,000

These calculations exclude closing costs, credits, earnest-money accounting and lender conditions. Ask for updated lender figures before proposing a split. “Meet halfway” can sound reasonable while leaving the buyer without enough approved funds to close.

Read the signed documents before choosing a response

Have your agent assemble the executed contract, financing addendum, appraisal-related addendum and amendments. Mark the closing date, applicable notice deadlines and required supporting documents. If a right is disputed or unclear, ask a Texas real estate attorney to interpret it before a deadline passes.

The TREC Third Party Financing Addendum, form 40-11, checked November 17, separates buyer approval from property approval. Paragraph 2B addresses property underwriting requirements, including appraisal. Its termination provision requires timely notice and a written lender statement explaining the determination; the stated deadline is on or before the third day before closing. Read the version and terms actually signed.

The TREC appraisal addendum, form 49-1, offers a waiver, partial waiver or additional termination right. The selected provision and completed blanks matter. This form says it is for transactions with the Third Party Financing Addendum that do not involve FHA-insured or VA-guaranteed financing. Do not copy a conventional-loan answer into an FHA or VA transaction.

An expired option period does not, by itself, answer every financing question. Equally, a disappointing appraisal does not prove the buyer has an unrestricted cancellation right. Keep inspection timing, financing protection and any separate appraisal agreement distinct. Our New Braunfels option-period checklist explains the separate inspection-stage calendar.

Request a focused review when the report contains a real issue

Ask the buyer’s agent for the report and coordinate through the buyer and lender. Identify specific facts: an incorrect property characteristic, a missing relevant sale or a comparison that deserves explanation. Provide records and a concise explanation instead of a demand to reach the contract price.

Freddie Mac’s seller appraisal guidance, checked November 17, recommends reviewing factual accuracy and using the lender’s correction procedure rather than contacting the appraiser directly. A review does not promise a higher value.

In New Braunfels, make the evidence address-specific. Explain why a proposed comparison resembles the subject’s location, site, size, condition and features. A nearby asking price is not the same evidence as a completed sale. An upgrade receipt documents spending; it does not establish an equal increase in market value.

The 2024 interagency reconsideration-of-value guidance, checked November 17, describes lender processes for reviewing relevant additional information and valuation deficiencies. Ask the lender about its process and timing. Do not assume a pending review extends your contract deadlines or guarantees closing on schedule.

Compare the choices using proceeds, time and certainty

Build a short decision sheet with three paths: close with this buyer at an amended price, close with documented additional buyer funds, or address a possible termination and return to market. For each path, write the estimated seller net, outstanding conditions and earliest realistic closing date.

A price reduction is a measurable concession. Returning to market carries less certain outcomes: another buyer’s offer, financing and appraisal may differ. Include your own documented mortgage interest, insurance, utilities, maintenance and moving arrangements when evaluating delay. Use your bills and plans, not a generic daily holding-cost figure.

The CFPB’s low-appraisal guidance, last reviewed September 11, 2024, explains that a buyer may seek a lower price and should consider contract terms before cancelling. A request to renegotiate is something to evaluate; it does not rewrite your agreement.

Use the seller net comparison guide for the proceeds calculation. Here the decision is narrower: resolving a lender valuation after a contract is signed. Before agreeing, verify lender acceptance, the amendment terms and the revised closing plan together.

Leave the conversation with a documented plan

Ask your agent to summarize the report issue, the lender’s current position, the relevant deadlines and each party’s proposed contribution. Keep valuation evidence separate from negotiation preferences. If you need help comparing the paths for your New Braunfels sale, contact Cody Posey with your contract timeline so the next discussion starts with the actual documents and numbers.